Rumsfeld, the recent supreme court case concerning the use of special military commissions to try guantanamo prisoners, is a bear to boil down, accurately, in a. Rumsfeld was a suit for a writ of habeas corpus brought on the behalf of yasser esam hamdi, an american citizen apprehended in afghanistan and detained on charges of being an enemy combatant. Paragraph lists four overt acts that hamdan is alleged to have committed sometime between 1996 and november 2001 in furtherance of the enterprise and conspiracy. Petitioner salim ahmed hamdan, a yemeni national, is in custody at an. Rumsfeld against the president of the united states and his effort to create a military tribunal system for purposes of trying those who are being detained in guantanamo bay, cuba. Judicious balancing at the intersection of the executives power to detain and the citizendetainees right to due process, 95 j.
Salim ahmed hamdan petitions for a writ of habeas corpus. I start from a premise that legislation is appropriate. The second act of the oath takes us to guantanamo, where salim hamdans military tribunal unfolds. After one year, hamdan was deemed eligible for trial by a united states military. Syllabus opinion stevens concurrence breyer concurrence kennedy dissent scalia dissent thomas dissent alito html version pdf version. Either method must address the concerns articulated in hamdan v. The time is not yet right to tell all of the backstory of the case, but it is possible to offer some preliminary re. The case questions the legality of guantanamo military commissions set up by the bush administration, whether the united states congress has the authority to pass legislation preventing the supreme court from hearing the case of an accused combatant before. The sole focus of this article is whether the offence of murder in violation of the law of war is a municipal common law offence rather than an erroneous attempt to identify a crime defined by international law. Salim ahmed hamdan, osama bin ladens former chauffeur, was captured by afghan forces and imprisoned by the u. For the reasons stated in respondents motion to dismiss, the detainee treatment act of 2005 dta, pub. The case powerfully illustrates both the promise and limits of domestic enforcement of international law.
Prisoners of war may not be tried in military commissions that do not afford the rights prescribed in the uniform code of military justice ucmj and the geneva conventions facts. While different approaches are feasible, i believe our nation will be best. He concedes that a courtmartial constituted in accordance with the uniform code of military justice ucmj, 10 u. In the paper harvard human rights journal, vol 20, spring 2007. Rumsfeld, docket number 036696, which focused on the detention of american citizens captured in hostilities overseas and classified an. Hamdan filed petitions for writs of habeas corpus and mandamus to challenge the executive branchs intended means of prosecuting this charge.
Nielsons determination is in direct contradiction to clearly established law. Rumsfeld in 2006, the supreme court noted that when the geneva conventions were drafted, they were intentionally broad, so as not to limit their protections. It wasn t because they didnt have a good editor and they were vague and evasive. Supreme court ruled in his favor in the landmark case of hamdan v. The supreme court has been the site of some of the great debates of american history, from child labor and prayer in the schools, to busing and abortion. Sanford levinson and the editors of this volume for offering their insights into the. Oxford guide to united states supreme court decisions. Salim hamdan us extraterritorial detainees wiki fandom. Landmark supreme court cases iii flashcards quizlet. Rumsfeld, and this comment is dedicated to my cocounsel.
Hamdan medical journal favors registration of clinical trials and is a signatory to the statement on publishing clinical trials in indian biomedical journals. Rumsfeld and the fight over presidential power 9780374223205. United states supreme court decision part 1 source. As the supreme court noted again in hamdan, the presidents powers, especially in wartime, are at their greatest when specifically authorized by congress. Salim ahmed hamdan defendant is a yemeni national who was captured by the united states government in 2001 and transported to guantanamo bay, a united states detention facility, in 2002.
Rumsfeld marks 2nd oral argument release during chief justice roberts tenure washington, d. He was charged with conspiracy and providing material support for terrorism but a judge declared the. Coeditor in chief, american journal of international law. Amazon first reads editors picks at exclusive prices. The decision sidesteps most of the bizarre complexities that have resulted from the supreme court. It wasnt because they didnt have a good editor and they were vague and evasive. Hamdan medical journal would publish clinical trials that have been registered with a clinical trial registry that allows free online access to public. In the hamdan decision, judge stevens, writing for the majority, addressed the boundaries of the law of war and specifically whether the conspiracy charge lodged against hamdan constituted a violation of this body of customary international law. Hamdan case and conspiracy as a war crime journal of. Hamdan was the case in which the high court invalidated the system set up by president bush to try accused war criminals at guantanamo bay, cuba. Rumsfeld and the fight over presidential power, on the other hand, is very much an outsiders account.
The oxford guide to united states supreme court decisions offers lively and insightful accounts of the most important cases ever argued before the court, from marbury v. Pdf international law has long been subjected to the charge that it isnt really. The circumstances that gave rise to it demonstrate the hurdles that domestic enforcement of international law faces in even the most robust democracies. Hamdi spent much of his life in saudi arabia, but maintained his american citizenship.
Rumsfeld 2005 involving osama bin ladens limousine driver, the court held that prisoner rights protected by the geneva convention could be enforced. Hamdans supreme court victory, however, did not lead to his release, but rather to congress redrafting the law on. Marine biofilm bacterial community response and carbon steel loss following deepwater horizon spill contaminant exposure. Swift born 1961 is an american attorney and former career navy officer, who retired in 2007 as a lieutenant commander in the judge advocate generals corps. The supreme court, in a fivetothree decision, resolved hamdan v. Archived from the original pdf on february 16, 2017. Rumsfeld, the supreme court ruled that the military tribunals at guantanamo bay violated the uniform code of military justice and the geneva conventions after his election in 2000, george w. This comment uses hamdan to illustrate why the disparagement of theory is.
986 913 70 760 849 973 1123 1184 424 932 1042 328 1355 712 1013 1558 1506 421 1379 834 353 1547 336 42 1218 1278 1381 569 367 1054 1410 714 1073 1445 912 1160 791 356 172 75 1270 1249 665 410 1255 669 653 934 766